Kings Langley ward has three licensed HMOs among 2,127 households, Dacorum says, too few for an Article 4 direction. Officers are looking at a threshold test.

Dacorum Borough Council will not seek extra planning controls over houses in multiple occupation in Kings Langley for now. The Leader, Councillor Symington, told Full Council on Wednesday 21 October that “the current evidence does not support an article 4 direction process at this time”.

She was answering two questions from members of the public, read out at the meeting. Both asked the council to look properly at an Article 4 direction for the parish. Her answers are set out in the printed draft minutes, published on 22 October.

The council’s figures for Kings Langley

The Leader gave the evidence behind the decision. It covers Kings Langley ward, which has 2,127 households:

  • four planning applications for HMOs in the last five years. One was withdrawn, and the other three were all for the same property.
  • three licensed HMOs in the ward, with no applications under way.
  • six HMO-related complaints since 2018. Three led to HMOs being licensed, and those three are among the figures above. Inspections of the other three found they were not HMOs.

Those figures were first sent to one of the questioners by the council’s Strategic Director for Place and Enterprise on 16 October, the minutes say.

Why the council says no

The Leader said the effect of HMOs has to be looked at across the whole borough first, and then locally. That is “critical to ensure that a targeted article 4 doesn’t simply displace the impact to the next street or settlement”, she said.

She also said:

  • there is no set threshold that would trigger an Article 4 assessment in Dacorum
  • officers are considering introducing a threshold test, in consultation with councillors, and will ask the Planning Officers’ Society and other councils about practice elsewhere
  • the position will be kept under review, and monitored as planning or licensing applications come in, or as complaints are made about possible HMOs that have not been through either process

What the residents asked

One question asked the Leader to commit to formally investigating an Article 4 direction for the parish, citing “growing national concern” about HMOs.

The second said officers had already made an initial assessment and decided that an immediate direction was “not appropriate”. A non-immediate direction was still under consideration, it said, with no timetable. It argued that the council’s assessment relied mainly on planning applications and licensed HMOs, although the council accepts that others may be operating without its knowledge.

It asked the council to publish its evidence and method, name the officer responsible, and set a timetable for a review. In reply, the Leader set out the ward figures and who in the council can make a direction. The minutes give no timetable for a review. Both questioners will get a written response.

What an Article 4 direction would change

Turning a family home into a small HMO, shared by three to six people who are not one household, does not normally need planning permission. An Article 4 direction withdraws that right in a defined area, so each conversion would need an application.

Government guidance describes two kinds (GOV.UK planning guidance):

  • a non-immediate direction, which a council consults on before it takes effect
  • an immediate direction, which withdraws the right at once but must be confirmed within six months, after local consultation. Councils must already have started work towards a non-immediate direction before they can use one.

The minutes say the decision to make an Article 4 direction is delegated to senior planning officers in Dacorum. It can also be sent to the Development Management Committee. Any decision by officers would be taken in consultation with the Strategic Director for Place and Communities and the portfolio holder for place.

What it means for you

If you live in Kings Langley, a neighbour can still turn a family house into a small shared home without planning permission.

  • If you suspect an unlicensed HMO, report it to the council’s housing team. The Leader said complaints and reports feed into the council’s monitoring.
  • If the council does set a threshold test, Kings Langley’s figures will be measured against it. We will report it when it is published.

Sources