Scrutiny councillors voted 7-6 to send the Hemel e-bike contract to Full Council on 16 December. The launch could slip from March 2027 to July or spring 2028.

Hemel Hempstead’s electric bike hire scheme has been sent to Full Council after councillors split 7-6 on Tuesday night. The vote means the contract cannot start yet, and the launch could slip from March 2027 to July 2027 or spring 2028.

Dacorum’s Cabinet awarded the contract on 22 September and released £1,004,690 of developer levy money. Five councillors then called the decision in. The Strategic Planning and Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee heard the call-in on 3 November.

Cllr Andrew Williams proposed sending it to Full Council and Cllr Neil Harden seconded. The vote was seven for, six against and no abstentions (draft minutes, 3 November 2026).

Why it was called in

The five councillors were Andrew Williams, Terry Douris, Graeme Elliot, Fiona Guest and Julie Banks. Most said they support the idea but not the size of the first scheme.

Their published reasons include:

  • Cllrs Williams and Douris: a smaller scheme that could grow once demand is shown would be better value
  • Cllr Elliot: the council may have “committed prematurely” when it could have run a time-limited pilot
  • Cllr Guest: “such a small number of people responded to the consultation” that it would not be a good use of Council Tax payers’ money
  • Cllr Banks: “we cannot deny the topography of Hemel Hempstead”, and a pilot would be better value

All five reasons are in the call-in record. The consultation Cllr Guest refers to is the survey we reported in September. It had 178 responses, and 54.49% of those who answered said they would not use the scheme (our earlier report).

What the council and the bidder said in reply

The officers’ report says a pilot would limit coverage and make it harder to judge demand. It says demand forecasts did not rest on the survey alone, but also on population, travel patterns and comparable schemes.

The winning bidder is still unnamed, but its comments are printed in the report. It argued against a smaller start:

“A smaller scheme will not build sufficient scale and would not be commercially viable therefore require further subsidy.”

The report describes the funding as mainly Community Infrastructure Levy, which developers pay, plus a £500,000 Herts IQ grant (call-in report).

What happens on 16 December

Full Council meets on 16 December, and it has limited power here. Under the constitution it cannot overturn a Cabinet decision unless the decision breaks the policy framework or the budget.

If councillors object, they can only send it back to Cabinet with their views. Cabinet then makes the final call. The report names 26 January 2027 as the next available Cabinet meeting.

What the report said each option would mean for the launch
RouteDecision dateEstimated launchExtra cost
No further action (not chosen)3 NovemberMarch 2027None stated
Back to Cabinet (not chosen)17 NovemberMid May to mid June 2027At least 2%
Full Council, no objection16 DecemberJuly 2027, or spring 2028 if missedMore than 2%
Full Council objects26 January 2027Spring 2028More than 2%

The report warns that all of these dates carry “significant risks”. The bidder says a launch after 26 January would run into supply delays around Chinese New Year. It says that would mean mid August at the earliest, so it would wait for spring 2028.

How big is the contract?

The value is still in a confidential report, but the published paper gives two clues.

It puts a 2% delay cost at “approx. £21,000”. On simple arithmetic that points to a contract of about £1.05m, though the council has not confirmed that figure. Any extra Community Infrastructure Levy money to cover the delay would need Cabinet’s agreement.

It also says the winning bid was not for the two smaller tender options. Those were capped at £1,050,000 and £850,000. The remaining option had a £1,300,000 ceiling and an indicative minimum of 170 bikes and 34 docking locations. The report says bids offered more bikes and bays at a lower cost than the tender required, without giving the numbers.

What it means for you

Nothing changes on the street for now. There are no docks, bikes or prices yet, and the operator has still not been named.

If you have a view, the people to tell before 16 December are your Dacorum ward councillors. We will report the outcome.

Meanwhile, our roadworks and travel page has this week’s closures, and parking in Hemel Hempstead has the current charges.

Sources